Equity Financing Or Debt Financing, Which One Is For You?
Saturday, February 27th, 2010One of the most important decisions facing managers in need of capital to fund their business operations is debt versus equity financing. Debt and equity are the two predominant sources of capital available to businesses, and each offers both benefits and drawbacks. The way that money is raised can have a tremendous impact on the success of a business.
Debt financing involves taking out loans that must be paid back over time, generally with interest. Businesses can borrow money over the short term (under one year) or long term (more than one year). Principal sources of debt financing are banks and government agencies, such as the Small Business Administration (SBA). Debt financing offers businesses a tax advantage—the interest paid on loans is typically deductible. It also limits businesses’ future repayment obligations for the loans, since the lender does not receive a share of ownership in the businesses.
However, there are some drawbacks. New businesses sometimes experience difficulty making regular loan payments when they have irregular cash flow. Debt financing can therefore leave these businesses susceptible to economic downturns or rising interest rates. Businesses that carry too much debt are more likely to be perceived as risky, and therefore less attractive to investors and less able to raise additional capital in the future.
Equity financing, by contrast, involves obtaining money from investors in exchange for an ownership share in the business. These funds may come from family members and friends of the business owner, wealthy investors, or venture capital furms. The principal benefit of equity financing is that the business is not obligated to repay the funds. Instead, the investors hope to realize a positive return on their investment in the form of future profits. The association with high-profile investors may also enhance a new business’ credibility.
The chief disadvantage to equity financing is that the investors become partial owners of the business and therefore gain some control over business decisions. As ownership interests are weakened, managers face the possibility that they could lose autonomy in operating the business. Also, businesses that rely excessively on equity financing are likely not making the most productive use of their capital.
Debt and equity financing are both important ways for businesses to obtain capital for their operations. Determining which to use or emphasize depends on the goals of the business and the extent of control managers would like to maintain. Experts recommend that businesses use both kinds of financing in a commercially appropriate ratio. This ratio, the debt-to-equity ratio, is a critical factor used by analysis to determine whether managers are running a business in a sound manner. While debt-to-equity ratios vary widely by industry and company, a reasonable ratio should generally fall between 1:1 and 1:2.
According to some experts, businesses should rely more on equity financing during the early stages of their development, since such companies may experience difficulty repaying debt until they achieve a consistent cash flow. On the other hand, many start-ups may have trouble attracting sufficient venture capital until they demonstrate strong profit potential.
In short, all businesses require sufficient investment capital in order to succeed. The most sensible strategy is to obtain capital from a variety if sources, using both debt and equity financing, and hire professional accountants and attorneys to facilitate financial decisions and transactions.